The following two tables set out the comparison in detail. 19 aspects of politics and the economy are evaluated, each with the strengths and weaknesses of the respective system.

Table 1: Strengths (advantages) and weaknesses (disadvantages) of the GDR
Strengths and weaknesses of the GDR
the GDRStrengths / advantagesWeaknesses / disadvantages
Land and property ownershipPublic ownership of land and property prevented speculative deals, few access restrictions (e.g., on the shorelines of bodies of water)A lack of personal attachment often led to careless treatment of land and property in many cases (e.g., at landfills or in agriculture)
Houses and apartmentsRents were very cheap, property prices were kept low by state directives, no land speculationDecay of rental apartment buildings in inner cities, stereotypical new construction on the city outskirts, private homeownership discouraged, purchase of real estate by the "average consumer" nearly impossible
Roadsno tollsCatastrophic condition of roads and highways
Public transportDeutsche Reichsbahn still operated on many branch lines that are now closedOutdated locomotives and rolling stock, a large backlog in track maintenance, decaying stations
IndustryPublic ownership of all larger enterprises prevented economic misconduct, with comparatively milder performance pressure (socialist competition)A centrally controlled planned economy prevented quick response to new market needs and suppressed individual initiative; necessary investments were often omitted, resulting in an increasingly dilapidated capital stock
Crafts and tradesCraftsmen such as electricians or plumbers worked together in crafts production cooperatives (PGH), gardeners in horticultural production cooperatives (GPG)No freedom of enterprise, tradesmen's services scarce
AgricultureFarmers worked together in Agricultural Production Cooperatives (LPG), which were supported by Agrochemical Centers (ACZ) and district enterprises for agricultural machinery (formerly Machine-Tractor Stations, MTS)Industrial-scale animal and crop production (large-area cultivation / huge livestock barns) with significant environmental burdens (over-fertilization and pesticide/herbicide use), supply gaps in agricultural products, e.g. fruit and vegetables
EnergyLow energy pricesLignite is the most important energy source, electricity and gas supply networks prone to failures
Education and upbringingA large number of nursery and kindergarten places available, low daycare fees, no school fees, no tuition fees at colleges and universities
HealthcareUnhindered access to preventive care and medical treatment for all GDR citizensWestern pharmaceuticals and medical technology available only in exceptional cases
EnvironmentVery high pollution of groundwater and surface waters, regionally very high air pollution; all types of waste were allowed to be deposited, and landfills were also opened for waste from the "West"
Water managementLow water charges; supplying the population with drinking water has priorityInsufficient maintenance of drinking water supply networks, resulting in high network losses and a significant shortage of wastewater treatment plants
Banks and the stock exchangeBanks are state-owned, thus there were no risky banking operationsLack of access to the international capital market, a "soft" currency, shortage of foreign exchange
CultureMany cultural events even in the "provinces"; tickets for cultural events were very cheap; the content offered was not only oriented to contemporary taste but sometimes also pursued educational aimsIsolation from the cultural scene in the "West"
FoodBasic groceries very cheapOverall product range very poor (e.g., there was a lack of tropical fruits, vegetables, fish and higher-quality cheeses as well as meat and sausage products)
ClothingBaby and children's items very cheapNot always up-to-date in fashion, limited selection
Consumer and household technologyLong lifespanOverpriced, because technical consumer goods were generally regarded as luxury goods, narrow product range (hardly any competing products), often technically outdated as well, waiting times for some products (e.g., color televisions)
CarsOverpriced, because cars were seen as luxury goods, long waiting times (10 years and more), few brands, technically outdated
Travel, sport and leisureExtensive range for recreational sports enthusiasts, low costsSignificantly restricted travel opportunities, doping in elite sport, limited availability of sports and recreational activities that demand high-quality equipment (e.g., sailing)
Table 2: Strengths (advantages) and weaknesses (disadvantages) of West Germany
Strengths and weaknesses of West Germany
West GermanyStrengths / AdvantagesWeaknesses / Disadvantages
Land and property ownershipPrivate plots and plots owned by companies are generally well maintainedHigh real estate prices, land speculation, fenced-off private areas (e.g., shorelines of bodies of water)
Houses and apartmentsExcellent maintenance condition of almost all properties; purchase of property possible for anyoneHigh rents
RoadsDense and largely intact network of roads and motorwaysToll charges
Public transportLargely modern fleet of trains and carriagesMany branch lines have been closed for reasons of profitability; there is a large backlog in maintenance of track infrastructure and stations; deficits in reliability and punctuality ("aftereffects" of the attempted IPO of Deutsche Bahn)
IndustryPrivate entrepreneurial decisions allow rapid response to new market needs and secure F&E as well as the necessary investments in new technology, thereby keeping the capital stock continuously modernCompetition in the markets creates massive performance pressure; economic offenses are lucrative and therefore recur
Crafts and tradesTradesmen's services available at any time; freedom of trade, thus also rapid response to new market situationsTradesmen's services expensive
AgricultureWide range of agricultural products (e.g., fruit, potatoes, vegetables, wine), use of the latest agricultural machinery (e.g., John Deere)Economic pressures lead to ever larger farm units (small farms are abandoned), environmental burdens due to over-fertilization and pesticide/herbicide use
EnergyEnergy supply is based on a steadily increasing share of renewable energyExtremely high energy prices (in international comparison) due to the shutdown of German nuclear power plants and due to the abandonment of natural gas and oil from Russia as a result of the sanctions
Education and upbringingHigh daycare fees, private schools with high tuition fees, access to colleges and universities requires financial means, shortage of crèche and kindergarten places
HealthcareLatest pharmaceuticals and state-of-the-art medical technology availableHigh health insurance contributions, especially for the chronically ill
EnvironmentLow burden on surface waters, low air pollution, landfills only permitted for inert waste
Water managementDrinking water and wastewater networks largely intact, sufficient treatment plants with very good removal efficiencies availableHigh fees for drinking water and wastewater
Banks and the stock marketAccess to the international capital market, "hard" currencyBanks in private ownership, speculation and other risky banking activities are common, bank failures possible
CultureCultural activity is concentrated in centers like Munich, Berlin, or Hamburg, few cultural events in the 'provinces', tickets for cultural events very expensive, offered content follows current tastes (e.g. TV ratings), resulting in a lot of 'trash'
FoodHuge range of products (incl. tropical fruits, vegetables, fish and higher-quality cheeses as well as meat and sausage products, wine)
ClothingWide product range, fashionably current, partly surprisingly cheapBranded goods expensive, no-name items often of inferior quality and limited durability
Consumer and household technologyHuge range of offerings (numerous competing products), inexpensive, technically state-of-the-artPartly short lifespans (“throwaway products”), unnecessary functionalities (“advertising gimmicks”)
CarsHuge range of offerings, virtually no waiting times“Overengineering” in some manufacturers and models
Travel, sport and leisureUnlimited travel opportunities (only limited by one’s budget), wide range of options for sports and leisure activitiesRelatively high fees charged by sports associations, especially for those with high equipment requirements (e.g., sailing, golf, riding), doping

Next: Attempt at a political-economic reassessment →